Expanding Your Horizon, Generation After Generation
Open house/inspection:
1582 W. State Road 114, North Manchester, IN 46962
Market Monday Auction! 100+ Beanie Babies of All Shapes & Sizes with More Lots Coming Soon!
Bid now through, Monday, January 26, 2026 - Lots begin closing at 6 pm
LOCATED AT: 1582 W. State Road 114, North Manchester, IN 46962


Lot #s & Descriptions:
30000 TY Princess Diana Beanie Baby with Tag, 4” x 4” x 5”
30001 TY Beanie Babies “Clubby” Bear in Display Case 6” x 6.5” x 8”
30002 TY Beanie Babies “Clubby” Bear in Display Case 6” x 6.5” x 8”
30003 TY Inc. “Britannia” Beanie Baby with Union Jack Ribbon – 4” x 4” x 7.5”
30004 2 TY Beanie Babies America Bear Pair with U.S. Flag Embroidery, 5.5” x 8”
30005 2 TY Beanie Babies ‘America’ Bears with Patriotic Design, 5.5” x 8”
30006 Teddy Grahams Plush Bear by Creature Comforts Toys Inc., 4” x 4” x 8”
30007 Teddy Grahams Plush Bear with "Chunky Chocolate" Embroidered Logo (case – no lid) 4.25” x 4” x 7.75”
30008 Teddy Grahams Plush Bear “Spicy Cinnamon”, in Clear Display Box, 4” x 4” x 8”
30009 Teddy Grahams “Chocolatey Chip” Plush Bear With Spots in Display Case, 4” x 4” x 8”
30010 TY Color Me Beanie Bear with Markers, 4.5” x 4.5” x 7.5”
30011 TY Inc. Beanie Babies Collection ‘Peace’ Bear 3.5” x 3.5” x 6.5”
30012 New York City Memorial Bear With 3 Hero 2001 Pins, 5.5” x 8”, 1” x 1.25”
30013 Holy Bears Inc. Plush Bear, God Bless Postal Workers, 5.5? x 9?
30014 Holy Bears Firefighter Bear Plush with Embroidered Patch and Tag, 5.5” x 9”
30015 The God Bless Our Police HolyBear Plush Toy 5.5” x 9”
30016 5 Coca-Cola International Bean Bag Plush Toys w/ Plastic Bottles Inc. Moose, Cow and Parrot, 3”-6”
30017 5 - 1999 International Coca-Cola Bean Bag Plush Toys Inc. Turtle, Pelican & Monkey, 3”-8”
30018 5 Coca-Cola Plush Animals Inc. Eagle, Tiger & Panda, 2”-8”
30019 5 Coca-Cola Plush Animals Inc. Koala, Poodle & Lion, 2”-8.5”
30020 9 TY Beanie Babies Inc. Garfield, Bears, and Animals, 3”-12”
30021 8 TY Beanie Babies Inc. Bears, Dolphin & Camel, 3”- 9”
30022 Hallmark Kiss Kiss Bears in Purple and Pink Outfits, 7” x 10”
30023 9 TY Beanie Babies Inc. Floppity, Blizzard & Waddle, 3”–9”
30024 9 TY Beanie Babies Collection Plush Toys Inc. Spangle, Peanut & Curly, 3” – 10”
30025 9 TY Beanie Babies Inc. Spangle, Valentino, Halo, Sly & More 3”-9”
30026 9 TY Beanie Babies Collection Inc. Erin, Peace & Iggy the Chameleon, 3”-9”
30027 9 TY Beanie Babies Inc. Squealer, Iggy & Cheezer, 3”-8”
30028 9 TY Beanie Babies Inc. Groovy, Ariel & Baldy, 3” – 11”
30029 9 TY Beanie Babies Inc. The End, Daisy & Freckles, 3” – 11”
30030 9 TY Beanie Babies Inc. Chicken, Hippo & Rhino, 3”-9”
30031 9 TY Beanie Babies Plush Toys Inc. Bears, Poodle, Bull & Spider 3” – 8”
30032 9 TY Beanie Babies Inc. Spinner, Spangle & Wallace, 3”-9”
30033 9 TY Beanie Babies Inc. Osito, Curly & Wallace, 3”-8”
30034 9 TY Beanie Babies Inc. Bears, Orcas & Nanook Dog 3” – 8”
30035 17 McDonald’s Happy Meals TY Beanie Babies in Original Packaging, 3” x 5”
30036 17 McDonald’s Happy Meals TY Beanie Babies Toyin Original Packaging, 3” x 5”
30037 20 TY Beanie Babies McDonald’s Happy Meal Toys in Original Packaging, 3”x5”
30042 McDonald’s Happy Meal Display Featuring TY Teenie Beanie Babies, 18?x19?
30043 9 TY Beanie Babies Plush Dolls With Tags Inc. Jabber, Peace & Clover
30044 9 TY Beanie Babies Plush Toys with Tags Inc. Bruno, Prance & Jolly
30045 9 TY Beanie Babies Plush Toys Inc. Bones, Paul and Blackie
30046 9 TY Beanie Babies Plush Toys With Tags Inc. Blizzard, Puffer and Strut
30047 9 TY Beanie Babies Plush Toys Inc. Gracie, Ringo and Puffer
30048 9 TY Inc. Beanie Babies Plush Toys with Original Tags Inc. Hippie, Hissy, Rainbow and Iggy
30049 9 TY Beanie Babies Plush Toys with Tags Inc. Mystic, Daisy and Gracie
30050 9 TY Beanie Babies Plush Toys with Tags Inc. Patriotic Bears, Kangaroo and Iguana
30051 TY Beanie Babies Plush Toys Inc. Patriotic & Dalmatian
30052 9 TY Inc. Beanie Babies, Inc. Smart, Millenium, and Osito
30053 9 TY Beanie Babies Plush Toys With Tags, Various Characters and STYles
30054 9 TY Beanie Babies with Tags Inc. Princess and Fuzz
30055 TY Beanie Buddy Plush Bear ‘Glory’ with American Flag Patch, 13?
30056 TY Beanie Buddies Clubby II Plush Bear, 13?
30057 TY Beanie Buddy Plush Bear ‘Spangle’ with American Flag Pattern, 13?
30058 TY Beanie ‘The Beginning Bear” Plush White Bear with Star Accents, 13?
30059 TY Beanie Buddy Plush Bear ‘Fuzz’, 13?
30060 TY Clubby Beanie Buddy Plush Toy, 13?
30061 TY Beanie Buddy B.B. Bear Plush Toy With Multicolor Design, 13?
30062 TY Beanie Buddy Coral Plush Fish with Tags, 8?
30063 TY Beanie Original Buddy Clubby II Plush Bear, 13?
30064 TY Beanie Buddy ‘Chilly’ White Bear Plush, 13?(Has A Stain)
30065 TY Beanie Buddy ‘Roam’ Plush Buffalo 6?
30066 TY Beanie Original Buddy Plush Dalmatian Dog “DotTY” 10?
30067 TY Beanie Buddy “Mystic” Plush Unicorn, 13?
30068 TY Beanie Buddy Hope Plush Bear with Heart Tag, 9?
30069 TY Beanie Buddy Plush “Bubbles” Yellow & Black Fish, 8?
30070 Beanie Original Buddy ‘Inch’ Rainbow Caterpillar Plush Toy, 6?x15?
30071 TY Beanie Buddy Plush Pumpkin “Pumkin'” Toy, 7?
30072 TY Beanie Original Buddy Plush Penguin “Waddle”, 10?
30073 TY Beanie Buddy RighTY Plush, 16?
30074 TY Beanie Buddy Plush Spinner Spider with 9? Tiger-Striped Body
30075 TY Beanie Original Buddy Erin Bear 13? Plush
30076 TY Beanie Baby Schweetheart Original Buddy Plush 12?
30077 TY Beanie Buddy Chilly Bear Plush Toy with Heart Tag, 13? (Has A Stain)
30078 TY Beanie Buddy Plush Toy ‘Inch’ Caterpillar 6?x15?
30079 TY Beanie Baby Millennium Bear 13? with Tags
30080 TY Beanie Buddy ‘Peanut” Plush Elephant in Royal Blue, 15?
30081 TY Beanie Original Buddy Spangle Plush Bear 13?
30082 TY Beanie Buddy Plush Bear Halo with Iridescent Wings, 13?
30083 TY 2K 1999 Beanie Buddy Plush Bear with Multicolor Spotted Design, 13?
30084 TY Beanie Buddy Peace Bear Plush Toy with Embroidered Peace Symbol, 13?
30085 TY Beanie Original Buddy Princess Diana Plush Bear 13?
30086 9 TY Beanie Babies Plush Toys with Tags inc. Batty, Erin, Knuckles, Ringo, Peace, Glory, Valentino, Curly, and Fortune
30087 9 TY Beanie Babies Inc Millennium, Signature Bear, Chocolate & Daisy
30088 9 TY Inc. Beanie Babies Plush Toys Inc. Curly, Peace and Glory, 6?-8?
30089 10 TY The Birthday Beanies Collection Bears, 8?
30090 9 TY Beanie Babies Plush Toys Inc. Claude, Starlett & Celebrate, 4-8?
30091 9 TY Beanie Babies Inc. Osito, Courage & Kirby, 6?-8?
30092 9 TY Beanie Babies Plush Toys Inc. TY2K, Signature Bear & Curly, 9?
30093 TY Beanie Baby Champion Bear with 2002 FIFA World Cup Tag, 8?
30094 11 TY Beanie Teenie Babies Lapel Pins, 1?
30095 11 TY Beanie Teenie Babies Lapel Pins, 1?
30096 11 TY Beanie Teenie Babies Lapel Pins, 1?
30097 10 TY Beanie Babies Inc. Jester, Spunky & Wisest
30098 14 TY Beanie Babies & Jingle Beanies Inc. Loosy, Ewey & 1997 Holiday Teddy
30099 Budweiser Dale Earnhardt Jr. NASCAR 2000 Commemorative Bottle, 15?
30100 Betty Boop Plush Doll with Pudgy, 8?
30101 New DeWalt D28474 Type 3 Angle Grinder, 8000 RPM, 120V AC, 15A
30102 Plush Toys, Inc. KFC Exclusives, Snax Friends, Gund and Limited Editions, 1999
30103 Rubbermaid 9.8-Gallon Plastic Underbed Storage Box
Payment is due the day following the auction at the scheduled pick up, unless otherwise stated on the auction. Metzger Property Services is not responsible for checking accounts for updated information including but not limited to addresses, phone numbers, valid credit cards, email addresses, etc.
Buyer accepts the terms by entering and bidding in the auction and recognizes that items are to be forfeited 5 days following the auction and that he or she is still responsible for all costs due regardless of the item(s) still being available.
All auction end times and loadouts posted are in Eastern Standard Time, unless otherwise noted.
If you continue to not pay for your items, at the end of each month there will be a 2% interest charge per calendar month (24% per annum) with a $10.00 minimum on each late invoice. There will be an additional $100.00 collection fee added the following calendar month of purchase.