Auction Information

Metzger Online Coin & Currency Auction

Gold - Error Coins - Morgan & Peace Dollars - Proof & Mint Sets - Marbles & Paperweights - Red Seal Currency - Indian Head Pennies - Seated, Standing, Walking Liberties & More!

Bid now through, Sunday, July 20, 2025 - Lots begin closing at 7pm       

Pickup for items will be the next day, Monday, July 21st - with the exact details to be in your winning invoice! 

Location: 1582 W. State Road 114, North Manchester, IN 46962

This auction will have NO sales tax, but will have a 10% Buyer's Premium added to your winning invoice 

BID NOW AT BIDMETZGER.COM

LOT#S & DESCRIPTIONS:

2000 1881-O Morgan Silver Dollar

2001 2011 1 Oz. American Silver Eagle Dollar

2002 1951-P Franklin Half Dollar

2003 1883-O Morgan Silver Dollar

2004 1923-P Silver Peace Dollar

2005 1896-P Morgan Silver Dollar

2006 2001 John Hammon Miller Blue, Pink, and White Paper Weight

2007 1849 Large Cent with Hole

2008 10- Buffalo Nickels, No Dates

2009 1930-S Standing Liberty Quarter

2010 10- Indian Head Pennies (1891-1907)

2011 2001 John Hammon Miller Pink, Green, and White Paperweight

2012 1942-D Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2013 1859 Seated Liberty Dime

2014 1925-P Silver Peace Dollar

2015 1927 Standing Liberty Quarter

2016 1951-P Franklin Half Dollar

2017 1998 Prestige Art Glass Studio, Red, Orange, White Paperweight

2018 10- Steel Wheat Pennies, 1943

2019 1921-P Morgan Silver Dollar

2020 1923-P Silver Peace Dollar

2021 1944-P Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2022 1951-P Franklin Half Dollar

2023 10- Buffalo Nickels, No Dates

2024 2001 John Hammon Miller Gold, Green, Blue and White Paper Weight

2025 1953 Red Seal $2 Note

2026 1928 Red Seal $2 Note

2027 1963 Red Seal $2 Note

2028 1953 Red Seal $2 Note

2029 10- Buffalo Nickels, No Dates

2030 2001 John Hammon Miller Light Blue, Dark Blue, Light Pink, Red, Yellow, Purple, White and Green

2031 10- 1943 Steel Wheat Pennies

2032 1921-D Morgan Silver Dollar

2033 1963 Red Seal $2 Notes

2034 1953 Red Seal $2 Notes

2035 1928 Red Seal $2 Notes

2036 2001 John Hammon Miller Red, White, Dark Green, Light Green and Black

2037 1930-P Standing Liberty

2038 1876-P Seated Liberty Quarter

2039 1847 Large Cent

2040 1951-P Franklin Half Dollar

2041 1847-P Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2042 3 China Stone Marbles

2043 1914 Barber Dime

2044 10- Indian Pennies (1901-1908)

2045 11- Indian Pennies (1901-1908)

2046 1923-P Silver Peace Dollar

2047 1884-O Morgan Silver Dollar

2048 3 China Stone Marbles

2049 1951-P Franklin Half Dollar

2050 1930–P Standing Liberty Quarter

2051 10- 1943 Steel Wheat Pennies

2052 1896-P Morgan Silver Dollar

2053 1962-P Franklin Half Dollar

2054 3 China Stone Marbles

2055 1951-P Franklin Half Dollar

2056 1854-Arrows Seated Liberty Half Dime

2057 1870-P Morgan Silver Dollar

2058 1924-P Silver Peace Dollar

2059 3 China Stone Marbles

2060 10 Buffalo Nickels, No Dates

2061 1896-P Morgan Silver Dollar

2062 10- 1943 Steel Wheat Pennies

2063 1923-P Silver Peace Dollar

2064 1885-P Morgan Silver Dollar

2065 3 China Stone Marbles

2066 1924-P Silver Peace Dollar

2067 1941-P Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2068 1886-S Morgan Silver Dollar

2069 1865 3 Cent Nickel, Error Coin

2070 1876 Seated Liberty Dime

2071 3 Large Benningtons Marbles

2072 10- 1943 Steel Wheat Pennies

2073 10- Indian One Cents (1906-1908)

2074 10- Buffalo Nickels, No Dates

2075 1926-P Silver Peace Dollar

2076 1925-P Silver Peace Dollar

2077 3 China Stone Marbles

2078 40- Jefferson Nickels (1940-1960)

2079 1898-P Morgan Silver Dollar

2080 1881-S Morgan Silver Dollar

2081 1942-P Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2082 1870 3 Cent Nickel

2083 3 China Stone Marbles

2084 10- Buffalo Nickels, No Dates

2085 1921-D Morgan Silver Dollar

2086 1922-P Silver Peace Dollar

2087 1958-D Franklin Half Dollar

2088 1951-P Franklin Half Dollar

2089 3 China Stone Marbles

2090 1881-S Morgan Silver Dollar

2091 1912 Barber Quarter

2092 1881-P Morgan Silver Dollar

2093 1902-O Barber Quarter

2094 1898-P Morgan Silver Dollar

2095 3 China Stone Marbles

2096 1921-S Buffalo Nickel

2097 1956-D Lincoln Wheat Penny, Error Coin

2098 1865 2 Cent Shield Nickel

2099 1918 Standing Liberty Quarter

2100 1896-P Morgan Silver Dollar

2101 6- Marble Kind Big Boy Glass Marbles, in original packaging

2102 1857-O Seated Liberty Half Dime

2103 10- Buffalo Nickels, No Dates

2104 1947-D Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2105 1922-P Silver Peace Dollar

2106 1974-S Lincoln Penny Roll

2107 3 China Stone Marbles

2108 1951-P Franklin Half Dollar

2109 1853 Large Cent

2110 1857 Flying Eagle One Cent

2111 1966-P Kennedy Half Dollar

2112 13- Roosevelt Dimes Inc. Proof & Double Die (1946-1981)

2113 3 China Stone Marbles

2114 1922-P Silver Peace Dollar

2115 1936-S Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2116 1890 Seated Liberty Dime

2117 185-S Barber Quarter

2118 1946 Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2119 3 China Stone Marbles

2120 1928 Standing Liberty Quarter

2121 1904-O Morgan Silver Dollar

2122 4- Lincoln Head Pennies Inc. Error Coins & Double Die (1982-1984)

2123 1938-D Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2124 1908-S Indian Penny

2125 3 China Stone Marbles

2126 1924-P Silver Peace Dollar

2127 1865 3 Cent Nickel

2128 1941-S Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2129 1887-S Morgan Silver Dollar

2130 1955 Poor Man’s Double Die Lincoln Wheat Penny

2131 4 China Stone Marbles

2132 1962-P Franklin Half Dollar

2133 1936-P Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2134 1849 Seated Liberty Half Dime

2135 1858 Flying Eagle Penny

2136 1926-P Standing Liberty Quarter

2137 Decorative Stone Egg

2138 1882-O Morgan Silver Dollar

2139 1882 Shield Nickel

2140 1940-P Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2141 1936 Buffalo Nickel

2142 1928-P Standing Liberty Quarter

2143 Decorative Stone Egg

2144 1879-S Morgan Silver Dollar

2145 1898-O Barber Quarter

2146 1945-D Silver Mercury Dime

2147 1927-P Mercury Dime

2148 1945 Lincoln Wheat Penny, Error Coin

2149 Decorative Stone, Brown/Burgundy

2150 1866 Indian Head Penny

2151 1879-P Morgan Silver Dollar

2152 40- Early Jefferson Nickels (1940-1960)

2153 1882-S Morgan Silver Dollar

2154 10- Buffalo Nickels, No Dates

2155 Large Assortment of Marbles

2156 1881-P Morgan Silver Dollar

2157 10- Steel Wheat Pennies

2158 1883-O Morgan Silver Dollar

2159 12- Buffalo Nickels (1923-1937)

2160 1904-O Morgan Silver Dollar

2161 Large Assortment of Marbles

2162 1994 Proof Set

2163 1958 U.S. Proof Set

2164 1/4 Grain 24K Fine Gold Bar

2165 1960-P Proof Set

2166 2001 U.S. Proof Set - 10 piece

2167 Large Assortment of Marbles

2168 1885-P Morgan Silver Dollar

2169 1937 Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2170 1884-P Morgan Silver Dollar

2171 10- Buffalo Nickels, No Date

2172 10- Steel Wheat Pennies, 1943

2173 Large Assortment of Marbles

2174 10- Indian Pennies (1902-1907)

2175 10- 1943 Steel Wheat Pennies

2176 10- 1943 Steel Wheat Pennies

2177 10- Indian Pennies (1899-1908)

2178 10- 1943 Steel Wheat Pennies

2179 Large Assortment of Marbles inc. Shooters

2180 1859 Seated Liberty Quarter

2181 1865 Indian Head Penny

2182 1928 Standing Liberty Quarter

2183 1830 Large Cent

2184 1908-D Barber Quarter

2185 Large Assortment of Marbles

2186 1863 Indian Penny

2187 1886 Seated Liberty Dime

2188 1972 Roosevelt Dime, Error Coin

2189 1909 VDB Lincoln Wheat Penny

2190 1864 Two Cent Shield

2191 Large Assortment of Marbles

2192 1884 Seated Liberty Dime

2194 1946-P Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2196 1851 Large Cent

2197 Large Assortment of Marbles

2198 1951-P Booker T. Washington Commemorative Half Dollar

2199 1946-P Booker T. Washington Commemorative Half Dollar

2200 10- 1943 Steel Wheat Pennies

2201 3 Dimes including, 1911 Barber Dime, 1914 Barber Dime, and 1936 Mercury Dime

2202 1922-P Silver Peace Dollar

2203 Decorative Stone Egg

2204 1944-P Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2205 6- Jefferson Nickels inc. error coins, key dates (1939-1982)

2206 1864 Indian Penny

2207 1936-S Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2209 1 1/2” Blue Glass Comtemporary Marble

2210 1943-P Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2211 1925-P Standing Liberty Quarter

2212 4- Lincoln Head Pennies Inc. Error Coin & Double Die (1961, 1977, 1986)

2214 1897-P Barber Quarter

2215 30 Mixed Slag Marbles

2216 1846 Large Cent

2217 1930-P Standing Liberty Quarter

2218 1844 Large Cent Coin

2219 1867 Mercury 3 Cent Nickel with Hole

2220 1945-P Walking Liberty Half Dollar

2221 5 Glass Master Marbles

2223 1899-P Barber Quarter

2225 1930-S Standing Liberty Quarter

2227 40 Vitro Cat Eye Marbles

2228 1930-P Standing Liberty Quarter

2230 1930-S Standing Liberty Quarter

2231 1858 Indian Penny

2233 40 Vitro Cat Eye Marbles

2234 1835 Capped Bust Dime

2236 1904 Liberty “V” Nickel

2238 5- Lincoln Head Pennies Inc. Error Coins & Double Die (1961-1986)

2239 60 Marble King Marbles

2241 1879 Indian Head Penny

2245 60 Marble King Marbles

2247 1858 Flying Eagle Penny

2251 60 Marble King Glass Marbles

2254 1919 Lincoln Wheat Penny

2257 60 Marble King Glass Marbles

2258 1920 Lincoln Wheat Penny, Error Coin

2259 1869 3 Cent Nickel

2260 1873 3 Cent Nickel

2261 1954-P Franklin Half Dollar

2262 1957-P Franklin Half Dollar

2263 1974-S Proof Eisenhower Dollar in Case

2264 1954-D Franklin Half Dollar

2265 1953-D Franklin Half Dollar

2266 2000 (10 piece) Proof Set

2267 1962-D Franklin Half Dollar

2268 1952-P Franklin Half Dollar

2269 1998-S United States Mint Proof Set

2270 1951-D Franklin Half Dollar

2271 1952-P Franklin Half Dollar

2272 2005-S United States Proof Set

2273 1950-D Franklin Half Dollar

2274 1959-P Franklin Half Dollar

2275 1997-S United States Proof Set

2276 1952-D Franklin Half Dollar

2277 1951-S Franklin Half Dollar

2278 1996-S United States Proof Set

2279 2- Eisenhower Dollar Coins (1972-D & 1976-D)

2280 2- Eisenhower Dollar Coins (1972-P and 1976-D)

2281 2- Eisenhower Dollar Coins (1971-D and 1972-P)

2282 2- Eisenhower Dollar Coins (1971-P and 1974-D)

2283 2- Eisenhower Dollar Coins (1972-P and 1976-D)

2284 2- Eisenhower Dollar Coins (1972-D and 1976-D)

2285 2- Eisenhower Dollar Coins (1974-D and 1976-P)

2286 2- Eisenhower Dollar Coins (1971-D and 1972-D)

2287 2- Eisenhower Dollar Coins (1971-P and 1972-P)

2288 2- Eisenhower Dollar Coins (1972-P and 1976-D)

2289 2- Eisenhower Dollar Coins (1971-D and 1972-D)

2290 2- Eisenhower Dollar Coins (1972-D and 1971-D)

2291 3 - 1976 Coins (Washington Quarter, Kennedy Half Dollar and Eisenhower Dollar)

2292 3 - 1976 Coins (Washington Quarter, Kennedy Half Dollar and Eisenhower Dollar)

2293 3 - 1976 Coins (Washington Quarter, Kennedy Half Dollar and Eisenhower Dollar)

2294 3 - 1976 Coins (Washington Quarter, Kennedy Half Dollar and Eisenhower Dollar)

2295 3 - 1976 Coins (Washington Quarter, Kennedy Half Dollar and Eisenhower Dollar)

2296 3 - 1976 Coins (Washington Quarter, Kennedy Half Dollar and Eisenhower Dollar)

2297 3 - 1976 Coins (Washington Quarter, Kennedy Half Dollar and Eisenhower Dollar)

2298 3 - 1976 Coins (Washington Quarter, Kennedy Half Dollar and Eisenhower Dollar)

2299 3 - 1976 Coins (Washington Quarter, Kennedy Half Dollar and Eisenhower Dollar)

2300 3 - 1976 Coins (Washington Quarter, Kennedy Half Dollar and Eisenhower Dollar)

2301 3 - 1976 Coins (Washington Quarter, Kennedy Half Dollar and Eisenhower Dollar)

2302 3 - 1976 Coins (Washington Quarter, Kennedy Half Dollar and Eisenhower Dollar)

2303 3 - 1976 Coins (Washington Quarter, Kennedy Half Dollar and Eisenhower Dollar)

2304 8- 1938-D & S Jefferson Nickels

2305 16 Jefferson Nickels (1938-1978) and 4 Roosevelt Dimes (1973-1977)

GENERAL:

All items are sold AS IS, WHERE IS with no warranties or guarantees.

Metzger Property Services accepts preview requests for further inspection of item(s) prior to bidding. If you are inspecting a vehicle or motorized item, Metzger Property Services only allows the item to be started to hear it run or operate -- it is NOT allowed to be driven.

All auctions are a soft close, unless otherwise listed, meaning that the auction does not end until all bids are completed. Lots close out 1 at a time. There is a countdown on the lots to let you know how much time remains on each lot. If any bidding happens in the last 2 minutes of the lot ending, the time does extend another 2 minutes. It is highly recommended that you are in the auction watching the lots close, not in your watchlist.

Metzger Property Services reserves the right to reopen an auction or bid if there are technical difficulties, to allow for fair bidding. Previous winning bids may no longer be valid in this situation.

Metzger Property Services reserves the right to use stock images for products. Products may not come assembled as shown in stock image. Buyers are responsible for reviewing all photos listed and/or scheduling a preview.

Once a bid has been placed and confirmed, it cannot be retracted. By placing a bid, the buyer agrees bid retraction is disruptive and interferes with the auction.

Payment is due the day following the auction at the scheduled pick up, unless otherwise stated on the auction. Metzger Property Services is not responsible for checking accounts for updated information including but not limited to addresses, phone numbers, valid credit cards, email addresses, etc.

Buyer accepts the terms by entering and bidding in the auction and recognizes that items are to be forfeited 5 days following the auction and that he or she is still responsible for all costs due regardless of the item(s) still being available. 

All auction end times and loadouts posted are in Eastern Standard Time, unless otherwise noted.

PAYMENT TYPES & FEES:

Valid Credit Card required for bidding approval. All bidding is in US Dollars (USD). You may pay with Cash, Check, Certified Check, Credit or Debit Card with 4% convenience fee, or Wire Transfer ($25 fee added to each Wire); If you pick your winnings up at our specified time and location for the auction listed above. There is a $5 minimum if you would like to pay with a Card. Any invoices paid with a card that are less than $5 will be rounded up to meet the minimum requirement.

For out of state buyers with an invoice total of $500.00 or greater, we reserve the right to ask that funds be in a certified form with either a Certified Check, Money Order or Wire Transfer ($25 fee added to each Wire). If you are an out of state buyer and are sending a freight driver, payments must be received by wire only prior to pick up.

Metzger Property Services reserves the right to request signed documentation stating a buyer will not issue a chargeback for a credit card payment or a stop payment for a check.

Metzger Property Services reserves the right to charge sales tax on each winning invoice. If you are Tax Exempt, please have your exemption form or the information you will need to fill one out ready at checkout! We do require an Indiana ST-105, a merchant certificate will not be accepted. We need a new one each calendar year on file, so plan accordingly. This is available in the documents tab of each auction.

Metzger Property Services reserves the right to charge a buyer’s premium to be added to each winning invoice.

Refunds will not be issued for payment type changes. Please make sure the correct card is on file that you would like charged.

If you request a refund and it is approved, only the bid amount and tax will be refunded when applicable. The buyer’s premium will not be refunded. If the invoice was originally paid for with a credit card, the 4% fee will NOT be included in the refund. All refunds will be sent via mail to the address we have on file – buyers are responsible for updating address. No partial refunds will be issued and credits will not be offered. To receive a refund, all items must be returned.

All titled items will have a $25 Title Administration Fee. It is the buyer’s responsibility to notify us if the address you registered with is different than the one you want the title mailed to. All titles are mailed signature required – no exceptions. Metzger Property Services reserves the right to hold any titles for items paid with check or card for 10 business days.

If you do not come to the load out time specified on the auction, a $10.70 handling fee will be added to your invoice and your card on file will be charged for your purchase total plus the 4% credit card service fee.

If a buyer habitually fails to pick up their items during the allotted time, a $53.50 late fee will be assessed on the invoice for the third late pick up and every late pick-up invoice following unless other arrangements are made with the office.

If the card on file declines, a $5.00 declined card fee will be added, and the buyer will be blocked until payment is received. If a buyer provides a prepaid card as the default on their account, they are responsible for making funds available to avoid extra fees.

If your card habitually declines more than once within a 30-day period, Metzger Property Services reserves the right assess a $50.00 declined card fee for the current invoice, and each invoice following. Your balance due must be $0.00 before your account will be reinstated.

If a check is returned for any reason, a $25 returned check fee will be added to the amount of the original invoice, the buyer’s account will be blocked and the invoice must be paid with cash, cashier’s check or wire before the account will be reinstated.

If you continue to not pay for your items, at the end of each month there will be a 2% interest charge per calendar month (24% per annum) with a $10.00 minimum on each late invoice. There will be an additional $100.00 collection fee added the following calendar month of purchase.

If a buyer has outstanding balances not taken care of, Metzger Property Services, LLC reserves the right to take legal action. Should that occur, the buyer is responsible for the invoice plus all fees associated with the legal process including but not limited to attorney’s fees, filing fees, court costs, interest, and late fees.

Metzger Property Services reserves the right to ban a bidder for non-payment, non-compliance, and/or habitual issues.

PICK-UP, TRANSPORT &/OR SHIPPING:

Pickup will be the following day by appointment only! Your winning invoice will be emailed to you -- pickup information and exact loadout times will be included in the body of that email through a hyperlink to www.signupgenius.com, where you can also book a pickup time slot! ** If you do not receive an email, please check your junk/spam mail! If you are unable to sign up, please call, text or email the office to schedule a pick up time.

Call: 260.982.0238 • Text: 260.572.8117 • Email: [email protected]

Buyer is required to bring their own packaging, help to load and/or equipment for loading unless otherwise stated on the auction.

Metzger Property Services reserves the right to obtain a signature verifying that all purchased items are received at the loadout. By signing their invoice, a buyer or any party they send to pick up for them, agrees that they have checked all lots and are accepting the items in AS IS Condition. Once the invoice is signed, Metzger Property Services is not responsible for missing items or the condition of items. No refunds will be issued after the loadout for missing items. If a buyer has any issues during a loadout, they must be addressed with the cashier present before signing an invoice for action to be taken.

 All issues must be addressed with the cashier present before signing an invoice to be assessed.

Any other potential refunds will be sent to the accounting department for further review.

If Metzger Property Services is to transport your item(s), there will be a minimum $20 service fee added to your invoice. We will only transport your item(s) if feasible for us, this is not guaranteed, and you should place bids accordingly. The fee will be assessed by the loadout staff if items are to be removed from the auction site the day of the loadout.

Items not picked up within 5 days will be resold at new owners’ expense, even if paid for. Items not paid for after 5 days will be resold. Buyer is still responsible for paying outstanding invoices before being reinstated to bid.

Shipping is available on small lots. Buyer is responsible for notifying Metzger Property Services of any shipping requests. Metzger Property Services does not assume shipping, even for out of state buyers.

Metzger Property Services reserves the right to include charges for insurance for shipping on invoices more than $100. Any fees will be included in the total shipping costs added to the invoice.

Buyer is responsible for paying for items in full prior to being allowed to pick-up or have items shipped. Shipping costs include the cost of shipping plus up to a $10.70 handling fee per invoice. If a bidder has multiple invoices within a 7-day time frame, items can be shipped together upon request to minimize shipping costs.

Buyer is responsible for all shipping/handling charges incurred including fees charged by delivery service for incorrect addresses. If items are returned to Metzger Property Services due to incorrect shipping address, Metzger Property Services reserves the right to not reship, or charge for the reshipment of the items.

At our discretion, shippable items may go to the UPS store. This may result in higher shipping costs. The UPS Store will reach out to you directly to collect payment. Metzger’s will only collect the handling fee in this case, but you will pay UPS directly for the shipping costs. Exceptions may apply.